AI Model Picker comparison
Claude Opus 5.5 vs GPT-6 Astra
Both products reached the final shortlist for the same buyer profile — Frontier Reasoning — in the AI Model Picker. Your answers favor maximum capability for hard reasoning, coding, and agentic work — cost is secondary to getting the task done.
Anthropic
Claude Opus 5.5
AA v4.3.2 · 2026-09-26 snapshot · Standard USD/MTok input/output $4/$20 with no long-context surcharge; cache reads $0.20, 5-minute writes $5, 1-hour writes $8. Batch $2/$10. Fast $8/$40 on the Claude API, Anthropic-managed Google Cloud, and Microsoft Foundry deployments hosted on Azure; caching/data-residency modifiers stack, and Fast is unavailable with Batch. US-only inference adds 10% to input/output and cache reads/writes on Anthropic-operated routes where supported; Foundry uses US Data Zone Standard. Bedrock and Google-managed Google Cloud have independent regional prices. Batch 300K output requires output-300k-2026-03-24; standard output stays 128K. Knowledge cutoff June 2026; retirement not sooner than September 22, 2027. Server-side tools can add usage fees; tool schemas/results and thinking consume billable tokens. · Not independently rated
OpenAI
GPT-6 Astra
OpenAI flagship · All amounts are USD per MTok; long-context bands apply to the full request, not just excess tokens. Standard <=272K input: input/output $10.00/$50.00, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00; >272K: input/output $20.00/$75.00, cached input $2.00, 30-minute write $25.00, 12-hour write $50.00. Batch <=272K input: input/output $5.00/$25.00, cached input $0.50, 30-minute write $6.25, 12-hour write $12.50; >272K: input/output $10.00/$37.50, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00. Flex <=272K input: input/output $5.00/$25.00, cached input $0.50, 30-minute write $6.25, 12-hour write $12.50; >272K: input/output $10.00/$37.50, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00. Fast <=272K input: input/output $20.00/$100.00, cached input $2.00, 30-minute write $25.00, 12-hour write $50.00; >272K: input/output $40.00/$150.00, cached input $4.00, 30-minute write $50.00, 12-hour write $100.00. Ultrafast <=272K input: input/output $60.00/$300.00, cached input $6.00, 30-minute write $75.00, 12-hour write $150.00; >272K: input/output $120.00/$450.00, cached input $12.00, 30-minute write $150.00, 12-hour write $300.00. Regional processing and FedRAMP add 10% where the model and route are eligible; region eligibility is separate from a quoted tariff. Server-side tools and their tokens can add charges. Ultrafast uses Responses with service_tier ultrafast, with global/US processing only; EU inference residency is unsupported. Separate rate limits apply. Product administrator settings are separate from API eligibility. · Not independently rated
| What differs | Claude Opus 5.5 | GPT-6 Astra |
|---|---|---|
| Vendor | ||
| Vendor | Anthropic | OpenAI |
| Positioning | ||
| Positioning | AA v4.3.2 · 2026-09-26 snapshot | OpenAI flagship |
| Price positioning | ||
| Price positioning | Standard USD/MTok input/output $4/$20 with no long-context surcharge; cache reads $0.20, 5-minute writes $5, 1-hour writes $8. Batch $2/$10. Fast $8/$40 on the Claude API, Anthropic-managed Google Cloud, and Microsoft Foundry deployments hosted on Azure; caching/data-residency modifiers stack, and Fast is unavailable with Batch. US-only inference adds 10% to input/output and cache reads/writes on Anthropic-operated routes where supported; Foundry uses US Data Zone Standard. Bedrock and Google-managed Google Cloud have independent regional prices. Batch 300K output requires output-300k-2026-03-24; standard output stays 128K. Knowledge cutoff June 2026; retirement not sooner than September 22, 2027. Server-side tools can add usage fees; tool schemas/results and thinking consume billable tokens. | All amounts are USD per MTok; long-context bands apply to the full request, not just excess tokens. Standard <=272K input: input/output $10.00/$50.00, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00; >272K: input/output $20.00/$75.00, cached input $2.00, 30-minute write $25.00, 12-hour write $50.00. Batch <=272K input: input/output $5.00/$25.00, cached input $0.50, 30-minute write $6.25, 12-hour write $12.50; >272K: input/output $10.00/$37.50, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00. Flex <=272K input: input/output $5.00/$25.00, cached input $0.50, 30-minute write $6.25, 12-hour write $12.50; >272K: input/output $10.00/$37.50, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00. Fast <=272K input: input/output $20.00/$100.00, cached input $2.00, 30-minute write $25.00, 12-hour write $50.00; >272K: input/output $40.00/$150.00, cached input $4.00, 30-minute write $50.00, 12-hour write $100.00. Ultrafast <=272K input: input/output $60.00/$300.00, cached input $6.00, 30-minute write $75.00, 12-hour write $150.00; >272K: input/output $120.00/$450.00, cached input $12.00, 30-minute write $150.00, 12-hour write $300.00. Regional processing and FedRAMP add 10% where the model and route are eligible; region eligibility is separate from a quoted tariff. Server-side tools and their tokens can add charges. Ultrafast uses Responses with service_tier ultrafast, with global/US processing only; EU inference residency is unsupported. Separate rate limits apply. Product administrator settings are separate from API eligibility. |
| Editorial rating | ||
| Editorial rating | Not independently rated | Not independently rated |
| Best for | ||
| Best for | Hard reasoning, agentic coding, and knowledge work where quality is the constraint. | Computer-use agents and hard reasoning with vision. |
Intelligence comparison
What actually differs
Structured comparison from canonical product intelligence — verification status and recent pricing changes included.
| Criterion | Claude Opus 5.5 | GPT-6 Astra |
|---|---|---|
| Model | ||
| Context window | 1000000 May be staleSource: Official documentation | 1050000 May be staleSource: Official documentation |
| Pricing | ||
| Input price per 1M tokens | $4 May be staleSource: Official documentation | $10 May be staleSource: Official documentation |
| Output price per 1M tokens | $20 May be staleSource: Official documentation | $50 May be staleSource: Official documentation |
Model
Context window
Claude Opus 5.5
1000000
GPT-6 Astra
1050000
Pricing
Input price per 1M tokens
Claude Opus 5.5
$4
GPT-6 Astra
$10
Output price per 1M tokens
Claude Opus 5.5
$20
GPT-6 Astra
$50
Features
What each one leads with
The standout capabilities recorded for each product in the recommendation data.
Claude Opus 5.5
- 1M context (verified on profile)
- 128K max output
- Adaptive thinking always on
GPT-6 Astra
- 1.05M context (verified on profile)
- OSWorld 2.0 72.6% (offline, self-reported)
- Image input modality
Trade-offs
Pros and cons, side by side
The strengths and the catches the decision tool already weighs for this buyer profile.
Claude Opus 5.5
Pros
- AA Intelligence Index v4.3.2: 58 (publisher-rounded; 2026-09-26 snapshot)
- CursorBench 4.0: 57.8% at Max effort in Cursor's evaluation (2026-09-26 snapshot)
- Cheaper than Opus 5 ($4/$20 vs $5/$25)
Cons
- Forced tool use and disabling thinking are breaking changes vs Opus 5
- Closed weights — no self-hosting
GPT-6 Astra
Pros
- 74.1% DeepSWE 1.1 (xhigh) at $4.43/task on the 2026-09-22 Datacurve board snapshot
- Largest OpenAI training run to date (Stargate)
Cons
- Enterprise tenants get it disabled by default
- AA Intelligence Index v4.3.2: 53 (publisher-rounded, Max effort; 2026-09-26 snapshot)
The verdict
Who should pick which
Assembled from the same recommendation fields the tool scores on — not a universal winner.
Both products are finalists for the same buyer profile, so this is a fit decision rather than a category decision. Claude Opus 5.5 is aimed at hard reasoning, agentic coding, and knowledge work where quality is the constraint. GPT-6 Astra is aimed at computer-use agents and hard reasoning with vision. Neither product has an independently verified rating here, so use the fit criteria and current product evidence rather than a synthetic score.
Choose Claude Opus 5.5 if…
Hard reasoning, agentic coding, and knowledge work where quality is the constraint.
Watch out for
Forced tool use and disabling thinking are breaking changes vs Opus 5
Standard USD/MTok input/output $4/$20 with no long-context surcharge; cache reads $0.20, 5-minute writes $5, 1-hour writes $8. Batch $2/$10. Fast $8/$40 on the Claude API, Anthropic-managed Google Cloud, and Microsoft Foundry deployments hosted on Azure; caching/data-residency modifiers stack, and Fast is unavailable with Batch. US-only inference adds 10% to input/output and cache reads/writes on Anthropic-operated routes where supported; Foundry uses US Data Zone Standard. Bedrock and Google-managed Google Cloud have independent regional prices. Batch 300K output requires output-300k-2026-03-24; standard output stays 128K. Knowledge cutoff June 2026; retirement not sooner than September 22, 2027. Server-side tools can add usage fees; tool schemas/results and thinking consume billable tokens.
Choose GPT-6 Astra if…
Computer-use agents and hard reasoning with vision.
Watch out for
Enterprise tenants get it disabled by default
All amounts are USD per MTok; long-context bands apply to the full request, not just excess tokens. Standard <=272K input: input/output $10.00/$50.00, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00; >272K: input/output $20.00/$75.00, cached input $2.00, 30-minute write $25.00, 12-hour write $50.00. Batch <=272K input: input/output $5.00/$25.00, cached input $0.50, 30-minute write $6.25, 12-hour write $12.50; >272K: input/output $10.00/$37.50, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00. Flex <=272K input: input/output $5.00/$25.00, cached input $0.50, 30-minute write $6.25, 12-hour write $12.50; >272K: input/output $10.00/$37.50, cached input $1.00, 30-minute write $12.50, 12-hour write $25.00. Fast <=272K input: input/output $20.00/$100.00, cached input $2.00, 30-minute write $25.00, 12-hour write $50.00; >272K: input/output $40.00/$150.00, cached input $4.00, 30-minute write $50.00, 12-hour write $100.00. Ultrafast <=272K input: input/output $60.00/$300.00, cached input $6.00, 30-minute write $75.00, 12-hour write $150.00; >272K: input/output $120.00/$450.00, cached input $12.00, 30-minute write $150.00, 12-hour write $300.00. Regional processing and FedRAMP add 10% where the model and route are eligible; region eligibility is separate from a quoted tariff. Server-side tools and their tokens can add charges. Ultrafast uses Responses with service_tier ultrafast, with global/US processing only; EU inference residency is unsupported. Separate rate limits apply. Product administrator settings are separate from API eligibility.
Common questions
Claude Opus 5.5 vs GPT-6 Astra
Answered from the verified figures on this page rather than general guidance.
Is Claude Opus 5.5 or GPT-6 Astra cheaper?
Which is rated higher, Claude Opus 5.5 or GPT-6 Astra?
Should I choose Claude Opus 5.5 or GPT-6 Astra?
What is the catch with Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6 Astra?
A head-to-head answers one question: of the two finalists for this buyer profile, which fits your situation. If neither “best for” line matches, run the full tool — its other profiles exist for different buyers.